Skip to content
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Daily Desk

Who Has Made Troy's Premier League Weekly Best XI?

In the wake of every set of English top-flight fixtures this season, BBC football analyst Troy Deeney reveals his team and gaffer of the week.

Presented below are the latest choices. What are your thoughts? Provide your views.

The Last Line of Defense

Jordan Pickford (Everton): A pivotal moment in Everton's 3-0 victory against the Blues came from his superb save to keep out Enzo Fernandez. The goalkeeper has come up when it counts in such moments for his club this season and, hopefully, he maintains this form for the national team during the World Cup. Just last week, he made a significant error versus Arsenal but has since picked himself up again to produce for the Toffees.

The Backline

Neco Williams (Nottingham Forest): It was a massive pivotal match for Forest when they visited Tottenham, with top-flight survival on the line for each team. And Williams produced a colossal display to guide his side secure a vital victory in the survival scrap. He provided a pair of assists, delivering when it counted.

Matty Cash (Aston Villa): I did not think West Ham provided a significant danger going forward but Cash remained resolute and held the line for Villa. He succeeded in just maintaining possession. He supplied a lot going forward and simultaneously shut down anything and everything the Hammers offered in attack.

James Tarkowski (Everton): It was yet another solid display from the Toffees defender. He exhibited his composure and command, and consistently where he needed to be. He produced important interventions when called for and, more importantly, served as a reassuring figure in their defense. How Chelsea must wish for a centre-back with such fortitude, especially in light of the shaky defending they have exhibited at times.

Engine Room

Chris Rigg (Sunderland): It amounted to a steady display from Rigg in a unforgettable Tyne-Wear derby. He did not do anything spectacular against Newcastle but he did everything exceptionally competently. With Rigg, you know the level of performance from him.

James Garner (Everton): He might have taken it easy on the back of receiving a call-up to the Three Lions team recently. But instead, he got on with it and put in a great display. It came in the form of a exquisite assist from him to Beto for his team's opener. As a former teammate with him at Watford, I know he's synonymous with high energy and physical presence. He has got it all and I trust he does well for England to play his way into that World Cup squad.

John McGinn (Aston Villa): He's their skipper, leader and heartbeat. It's been two huge displays in the space of a week from him. Villa can be considered a decent team. But McGinn elevates them to a great one. If they are to secure the top five and challenge for the Europa League title, they will need him to keep producing at this level.

Harry Wilson (Fulham): He has developed a tendency of netting crucial strikes and he did exactly that again in the latest round. I wonder how the club are going to replace him if he chooses to leave. They are unlikely to spend £60m on somebody with his qualities. They need him to put pen to paper on a new deal as he is a massively important part of that Fulham set-up.

Front Line

Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United): It feels like the Portugal playmaker is becoming a staple in the team of the week. You have to include him once again following one more goal, and also being involved in the James Hill own goal. How long can United stay uninspiring and hold onto him before he decides it is time to exit the club?

Beto (Everton): This week, we have a pair of strikers who are at opposite points in their professional journey. I am not sure Beto is a lasting solution for Everton's goalscoring problems, but manager David Moyes is getting a tune out of him right now. It is notable in light of how ineffective he was in the initial months.

Danny Welbeck (Brighton): He was omitted by the England manager once more for the England squad, at a time when they require cover to captain Harry Kane. But Welbeck kept on perform for the Seagulls with a two goals, to defeat reigning champions Liverpool, and increase his goal count to 12 goals for the season.

The Tactical Mastermind

David Moyes (Everton): The fixture between Everton and Chelsea was a classic embodiment of traditional against new school. Chelsea's manager Liam Rosenior is still trying to carve his path at the outset of his managerial journey but Moyes put together a flawless gameplan to engineer a convincing win. The Toffees were more adventurous and more robust in each area of the game and it was a enormous win for them.

Do you agree with Deeney's choices? Which players would make up your weekly best XI? Share your thoughts.

About the author

Cheryl Jackson

Maya Chen is a seasoned journalist and productivity expert who writes about current events, technology, and work-life balance.

Daily Desk

Type to search articles.